TW: Descriptions of abuse and exploitation of disabled people
General warning: No, I don't actually think this is a particularly good proposal as far as having hard facts. But the professor says story is better than statistics, and that stories should grab people. I think I avoided making the disability itself seem tragic or portraying the people with disabilities inherently more innocent, at least. And there are some statistics in the relevant articles.
Liu Xiaoping is covered in third-degree burns. He has
marks on his wrists from the chains used to keep him from running away at
night. He is not a fictional character. He is a 30-year-old man who spent 10
months held captive in a brick factory. He was tricked there because of an intellectual
disability. When he became too weak to work anymore, he was thrown out on the
street, where he was eventually found. We only know about his story because He
Wen is also missing, presumably also held at a brick factory. He went missing
over a year ago, and his father, He Zhimin, stumbled upon Xiaoping while
searching for Wen. Liu Xiaoping, He Wen, and others like them are recruited
with the promise of the equivalent of $10 per day, which they never see.
Instead, the equivalent of $4.50 per day is paid to the person who recruited
them for each worker she brings. Even with the essential enslavement of workers
with intellectual disabilities, the brick factories are still often short on
labor, as it is difficult to find workers willing to work in the brick
factories. Perhaps this is why there is a demand for workers with intellectual
disabilities, who are perceived as easier to trick, easier to control, and less
likely to be searched for with any determination.
How does the exploitation of those with intellectual
disabilities affect China-the individuals, the families, the businesses, the
social structures and perceptions of people with disabilities, and the economy
in general? Do these stories about the exploitation actually lead to real
changes? What else can the narrative of disability in China look like?
Disabilities
are not limited to the intellectual, of course, nor are they always present from
birth. Some disabilities are acquired, like those of Li Nan and Zhang Haidi. One
day, Li Nan was a renowned dancer. The next, a car accident left her in a
wheelchair with both legs amputated. This could happen to anyone. The Premier
visited her, and she commented on the need for better accessibility in public
spaces. There is now a law in China mandating wheelchair accessibility. Zhang
Haidi acquired her disability at a younger age, becoming paraplegic at the age
of five from a surgery to remove tumors from her spine. While she attempted suicide
at one point, she also later became a poster child for the revolution when it
spoke about people with disabilities, and she currently heads China's Disabled
Person's Federation. She was among the first people with paralyzed limbs to
obtain a driver’s license in China under regulations that allow for driving a
modified car after a three month training period.
These two examples serve to show that just because we
and our loved ones are fully able now, we do not know that this will remain the
case. Disabilities exist. They always have, and they always will. The question
I think needs answering is how disability affects Chinese society? How does disability
affect the Chinese national economy? What about the personal finances of people
with disabilities in China and the finances of their households? What effects
can the way the government defines and provides (or does not provide)
accommodation for disability have on the personal, family, and community scales
in China? Essentially, how does China handle disability, and what economical
effects result from the intersection of disability and Chinese culture?
Sources:
Demick, Barbara. "China's
Disabled Exploited as Slaves." Los Angeles Times. N.p., 26 Feb.
2011.
Web. 9
Sept. 2012.
Levi, Eric. "Disability Rights in
China." Disaboom. N.p., n.d. Web. 9 Sept. 2012.
"Zhang Haidi." Chinaposters.net.
N.p., 29 July 2012. Web. 9 Sept. 2012.
Articles
relevant to the question:
Loyalka, Prashant, Lan Liu, Gong Chen,
and Xiaoying Zheng. The Economics of Disability in
China. Working
paper. Rural Education Action Project, May 2012. Web. 9 Sept. 2012.
Weiss, Thomas C. "Overview of
Disability in China." Overview of Disability in China. Disabled
World, 16 Mar. 2010. Web. 9 Sept. 2012.
No comments:
Post a Comment
I reserve the right to delete comments for personal attacks, derailing, dangerous comparisons, bigotry, and generally not wanting my blog to be a platform for certain things.